🔥 Trending on HN

When AI Answers First, What Happens to the Sites Behind the Help?

2 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
AI Overviews

Google search summaries made by AI.

Hacker News

A website where people discuss technology.

Gemini

Google’s AI model.

What happened

Nicolas Bouliane runs All About Berlin, a guide website for people living in Germany. In a May 26, 2026 post, he says traffic fell 75% after Google, the search company, expanded AI Overviews, its AI search summaries. The post includes a traffic chart. It describes a new path: ads, an AI answer, and then a link to the original page. Bouliane says many visitors now stop at the answer.

Why the site matters

All About Berlin began in 2017. It became Bouliane’s full-time work in 2020. The site offers practical guides about housing, jobs, banks, insurance, government offices, and daily life in Germany. Bouliane says government offices have referred people to his guides. He also says Berlin’s immigration office uses information about itself from the site. These are statements in his post, not independently audited findings. Still, they show what could be lost when detailed local guidance becomes hard to find.

Why this matters

AI answers can save readers time. They can also move attention away from the pages that supplied useful information. If fewer people visit, a site may lose income. Bouliane says he is preparing for a future in which the site cannot pay his rent. He argues that the problem is personal as well as financial. His carefully written explanations may appear inside a machine answer, while readers never meet the writer or return to the site.

The wider concern is maintenance. A guide about immigration needs updates when processes change. If income disappears, the writer may stop updating. Bouliane says other site owners contacted him privately. He says some added paywalls, while others stopped maintaining their sites. Those reports suggest a broader concern, but they do not measure the whole web.

What the evidence confirms

The post reports one publisher’s 75% traffic loss, a business problem, and concerns about similar publishers. The story also drew attention on Hacker News, a technology discussion site, with 257 points and 215 comments. That count measures community interest. It does not prove the traffic number or its cause.

Google’s official May 20 announcement says it is testing ads built with Gemini, Google’s AI model, in AI Mode. It also describes more AI-powered ad formats for Search. Google did not announce that every link would disappear. TechCrunch reported that links remain, but may receive less priority in many searches.

What remains unknown

The post does not show the analytics dashboard, search terms, referral breakdown, or comparison with other sites. We therefore cannot say that AI Overviews caused all of the 75% decline. We also cannot know whether the drop will last, whether visitors still arrive through other channels, or whether Google’s new designs will send meaningful traffic back.

What to watch next

Watch All About Berlin’s traffic, income, and update frequency. Watch whether AI answers cite and send readers to the original guides. Watch whether other independent publishers report similar, measured changes. The central question is simple: if AI uses the web’s careful explanations, can the people who maintain those explanations still reach readers and earn enough to continue?

💬 Is AI killing websites, or changing the web’s incentives?

The Hacker News discussion frames All About Berlin’s trouble as both a traffic problem caused by Google’s AI summaries and a larger question about how public information should be funded. Some commenters value the convenience, so there is no consensus.

  • In the author’s own report, the situation has worsened since the article was written, but the site still supports his living. He says next year may be his last year running it full time.
  • Google AI Overviews can combine information from several sites directly on the results page, so users may get an answer without opening the source. Commenters see this as weakening the link between useful work, visitors, and income.
  • Some users report from their own experience that an AI summary is more convenient than visiting pages filled with ads, paywalls, outdated information, or affiliate incentives. Others deliberately skip the summary and follow the original links.
  • The central paradox is that AI search depends on new human-made information while potentially reducing the audience, revenue, and motivation needed to publish that information. Commenters worry that fewer sources could eventually make answers less fresh or reliable.
  • A strong counterargument is that Google had already been controlling rankings and clicks before AI, and never guaranteed free traffic forever. Others note that technology previously displaced magazines and guide businesses, so platform dependence may be a bigger issue than AI itself.
  • Proposed remedies include separating model training from agentic access to information, licensing training use, and sharing revenue or making micropayments when search answers rely on a source. Commenters also note that fairly measuring each source’s contribution is difficult.
  • The unresolved issue is not simply whether AI is useful. It is who creates the public information AI depends on, how that work remains sustainable, and how creators should be compensated when users no longer visit the source.

initial digest at 215 comments (revision 1). We fetched 100 comments and sampled 100 across the thread. These are HN users’ reports, not independently verified facts.

🔥 Trending on HN

AI answers may hide the sites that do the hard work

📰 Full story: When AI Answers First, What Happens to the Sites Behind the Help?

One German guide site says Google’s AI answers cut its visitors by 75%.

2 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
AI Overviews

AI summaries shown in Google Search.

Hacker News

A website where people discuss technology.

Gemini

Google’s AI model.

💡 The gist

  • All About Berlin helps people move to and live in Germany.
  • Its owner reports a 75% traffic loss after AI Overviews grew.
  • Hacker News noticed the story, but attention is not proof.

All About Berlin is a website run by Nicolas Bouliane. It began in 2017. It became his full-time job in 2020. The site explains housing, jobs, banks, insurance, and government forms. These topics can feel confusing for newcomers.

Bouliane says the site had seven years of growth. Then, traffic dropped by 75%. That means only one quarter remained. If 100 people visited before, about 25 visited afterward. The number comes from his report.

He connects the drop with Google, the search company, and AI Overviews. This feature shows an AI answer near the top of search. People may read that answer without opening the original website. The answer can feel faster. However, the website may lose readers, income, and feedback.

Bouliane says the problem is not only money. He spent years writing clear guides. He says government offices have used or referred to his information. He also says other website owners shared similar worries. Some added paywalls. Others stopped updating their sites.

Hacker News gave the article 257 points and 215 comments. That shows strong community interest. It does not confirm the 75% drop. It does not prove that AI caused every lost visit.

Google announced tests using Gemini, its AI model, in search advertising. The company says AI-powered ads will appear in search experiences. Google did not announce that all links would vanish. TechCrunch reported that links remain, but often receive less attention. Google’s announcement and TechCrunch’s report explain the change.

Important details are still missing. The post does not show its full analytics. We cannot compare its traffic with every other website. We also do not know whether the drop will continue.

The next question is practical. Can independent sites keep earning enough to stay useful? Watch traffic, updates, and links from AI answers. A fast answer helps readers. The original guides still need people who can maintain them.

💬 AI summaries make answers easier, but websites harder to sustain

Commenters say AI summaries can be useful while also taking away the visitors and income that support information websites.

  • In the author’s own report, the site still supports him, but he is unsure how long he can run it full time.
  • Google can show an answer on the search page, so users may not open the original website.
  • Some users report that summaries are more convenient than ad-filled or outdated pages. Others skip the summary and read the source links.
  • AI needs new human-written information, but its summaries may reduce the reward for publishing that information. If sources disappear, answers may become less fresh.
  • Other commenters blame dependence on Google and ordinary technological change. Suggested fixes include licenses, revenue sharing, and micropayments, but no solution is agreed on.

initial digest at 215 comments (revision 1). We fetched 100 comments and sampled 100 across the thread. These are HN users’ reports, not independently verified facts.

🔥 Trending on HN

When AI answers first, who visits the helpful site?

📰 Full story: When AI Answers First, What Happens to the Sites Behind the Help?

A computer answer may make fewer people visit the person who wrote the guide.

1 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
AI Overviews

Computer-made answers shown in search.

Hacker News

A place for people to share tech stories.

Gemini

Google’s computer helper.

All About Berlin (a website about living in Germany) helps people. Nicolas Bouliane (the site owner) runs it. He wrote a post about fewer visitors. Google (a search company) has AI Overviews (computer-made answers). Nicolas says visitors fell by 75 percent.

Before, people clicked the site’s link. Now, some people stop at Google’s answer. The site may then earn less money.

Hacker News (a place for tech stories) noticed the post. It showed 257 points and 215 comments. That means many people noticed it. It does not prove the story is true.

Google is testing Gemini (Google’s AI helper) in search ads. Search may keep changing. We will watch whether people return to the helpful site.

💬 AI can help people, but it may hurt the people who write the answers

AI gives answers quickly. The writers who made the information may then get fewer visitors.

  • The author says his website still helps him live, but he worries he cannot keep doing it forever.
  • Google’s AI can show the answer without sending people to the website. Some users find this convenient, while others still visit the source.
  • AI uses information written by people. If people stop writing, AI may have less good information to use. Some want creators to be paid; others say this is just how technology changes jobs.

initial digest at 215 comments (revision 1). We fetched 100 comments and sampled 100 across the thread. These are HN users’ reports, not independently verified facts.

Sources