🐾 Creatures

Crows made a visual choice in 235 milliseconds. Here is what that means.

2 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
carrion crow

A crow species used in the experiment.

neuron

A cell that carries information in the brain.

millisecond

One thousandth of a second.

What happened

Researchers at the University of Tübingen, a German research university, studied two carrion crows, a crow species. Their paper appeared in Science, a research journal. The birds watched moving dots on a touchscreen. They judged whether most dots moved left or right. They showed their choice by pecking a target on the matching side. The average response took 235 milliseconds. One second has 1,000 milliseconds, so 235 milliseconds is shorter than one-quarter second. That is roughly twice as fast as comparable times reported for humans and monkeys. Those human and monkey results came from earlier studies. The researchers did not test all three groups together.

How the task worked

The screen showed white dots on black. Some dots moved together. Others moved randomly. The researchers changed how much motion pointed one way. Clear motion made the answer easier. Confusing motion made it harder. With clear patterns, the crows were almost 100 percent correct. With weak patterns, they still performed above chance. This matters because speed can come from guessing. The crows kept high accuracy while choosing quickly.

Why the result matters

A fast visual choice helps an animal react to its surroundings. Birds must guide their bodies while flying. They also need to aim their beaks precisely. The researchers suggest these demands may have favored rapid visual and movement control. That is a possible evolutionary explanation, not a proven cause. The finding also challenges a simple idea: advanced decision processes require a mammal-style brain.

What the recordings confirm

Researchers recorded neurons while the crows performed the task. About 70 milliseconds after the dots appeared, direction-related signals began to differ. The birds responded about 170 milliseconds later. Neural activity rose as the available visual evidence became stronger. It reached a decision threshold when the bird chose. This pattern resembles decision processes studied in primates. It suggests the birds were evaluating evidence, not merely twitching toward a target.

What remains unknown

Only two crows took part. The task measured one kind of visual decision. A result in this test does not show that crows decide faster in every situation. The human and monkey comparison was also indirect. The study cannot yet identify the exact biological feature behind the speed. Birds lack the layered outer cortex found in mammals, but researchers do not yet know which alternative features matter.

What to watch next

Future studies can test more crows and other bird species. They can use different kinds of choices. Direct tests can place birds, humans, and monkeys under the same rules. Researchers can also trace how signals move through the bird brain. The main lesson is careful: different brain designs can reach similar decisions, and one design may do it faster in one narrow task.

🐾 Creatures

Crows read moving dots very quickly

📰 Full story: Crows made a visual choice in 235 milliseconds. Here is what that means.

Two crows chose the main direction in 235 milliseconds.

2 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
carrion crow

A crow species used in the experiment.

millisecond

One thousandth of a second.

accuracy

How often an answer is correct.

💡 The gist

  • Two crows watched white dots on a black screen.
  • They chose left or right in 235 milliseconds.
  • Their brains began sorting the answer before pecking.

Researchers at the University of Tübingen, a German university, studied two carrion crows. The birds watched dots on a touchscreen. Most dots moved left or right. A few dots moved randomly. Each crow pecked a target on the matching side.

Clear patterns produced nearly 100 percent correct answers. Hard patterns still beat random guessing. This matters because a fast answer is not useful when it is often wrong. The crows kept high accuracy while answering quickly.

235 milliseconds is very short. One second has 1,000 milliseconds. Since 235 × 4 = 940, it is shorter than one-quarter second. Earlier tests with people and monkeys took about twice as long. Those tests did not include these same crows. So the comparison is useful, but it is not a perfect race.

Scientists also recorded brain cells during the task. About 70 milliseconds after the dots appeared, left and right signals began to differ. The crows answered about 170 milliseconds later. Their brains started sorting the picture before their beaks moved.

The task separated seeing from moving. The first brain change came long before the peck. That delay helps researchers study when a choice begins. It does not mean the bird solved a human-style puzzle. It means the bird quickly read one kind of visual evidence.

Bird brains have a different shape from human brains. Birds do not have the same layered outer brain. Still, both can gather clues and choose an answer. Fast vision may help birds steer during flight. It may help them guide their beaks toward food. This is a possible reason, not a proven answer.

The study has limits. It used two crows and one visual task. It does not show that crows think faster in every situation. Future tests should include more birds and harder choices. They should also compare birds and people under the same conditions. Researchers still need to find what makes the crow brain so fast.

🐾 Creatures

Crows chose a side very fast

📰 Full story: Crows made a visual choice in 235 milliseconds. Here is what that means.

Two crows watched moving dots and picked left or right.

1 min read Tiny Why Newsroom · By Curio, Martian correspondent

Words
millisecond

A very tiny unit of time.

signal

A small message inside the brain.

White dots moved on a black screen. Some dots went left. Some dots went right. The crow watched them. Then it pecked the matching side.

It took about 235 milliseconds. That is less than one quarter of a second. The crow was often right. It beat guessing when the dots were confusing.

The crow brain started choosing before the beak moved. A brain signal appeared about 70 milliseconds after the dots began.

But this was a small test. Only two crows took part. The test used one kind of picture. We do not know every choice a crow can make.

Sources