NASA wants to choose science missions faster—and more often
Competition Model 2.0
NASA’s new system for choosing science missions.
flagship missions
Very large NASA space missions.
principal investigator
The scientist who leads a mission team.
What happened
NASA, America's space agency, is changing how it chooses and develops science missions. The new plan is called Competition Model 2.0, or CM 2.0. Nicola Fox, NASA's associate administrator for science, described it in an Oct. 21 letter. Space.com reported the plan, and NASA published the official letter. The goal is to cut proposal work, lower costs, and move strong science ideas forward faster.
The main change is the order of review. NASA wants to judge the science first. Teams can delay detailed engineering, cost, and operations work until those details are needed.
Why the old process caused problems
NASA often invites teams through formal mission competitions. Under the older two-step process, teams had to provide extensive technical and financial material before NASA chose finalists. The process could take almost three years. Teams that lost still spent significant time and resources.
NASA says the burden made it harder to bring good ideas forward. A shorter first proposal could let researchers spend more time on the science itself. It could also give smaller teams a fairer chance.
What changes by mission type
Discovery, New Frontiers, and Astro-Probes will keep two stages. Their first proposal will focus on three items: a strong science case, a science implementation plan, and a proof-of-concept mission design. NASA says this removes roughly half the first-stage material. The selection timeline could shrink from 35 months to about 19.5 months, a reduction of up to 45 percent.
MIDEX and Earth Explorer missions will also use two stages. Universities and commercial organizations will have broader access. NASA will examine whether developers have delivered projects of similar size and complexity. Teams led by a principal investigator may request help from Goddard or the Jet Propulsion Laboratory.
Smaller programs will change more. Small Explorer, Earth Venture, Missions of Opportunity, hosted payloads, and rideshares will move to one selection stage. Reviews will use smaller teams and virtual site visits. Final selection could fall from about 32 months to about 19 months, or up to 40 percent faster. Large flagship missions will keep their current process, which already reflects lessons from the James Webb Space Telescope.
Why it matters
The reform could change who gets to compete. NASA says established and first-time teams should be judged more on scientific merit. The agency also wants commercial space capabilities used when they offer technical or cost benefits. More direct roles for Goddard and JPL may preserve expertise while reducing competition between NASA centers.
What is confirmed
This is a change to the selection system. It is not proof that a new spacecraft will launch sooner. NASA will still enforce cost and schedule controls. Breaking those limits could lead to serious consequences, including mission cancellation.
What remains uncertain
NASA says it will introduce the changes in stages and refine them with feedback. We do not yet know whether more teams will apply, whether review quality will hold, or whether missions will actually cost less. A shorter competition does not automatically mean a shorter build or launch schedule.
What to watch next
The next test will be the new calls for proposals. Their rules will show how much work teams really save. Later selections will show whether universities, companies, and first-time teams gain access. The strongest evidence will come from real missions: their science results, costs, and schedules.
NASA will choose space science ideas faster
📰 Full story: NASA wants to choose science missions faster—and more often
NASA, America's space agency, wants to shorten mission competitions.
mission
A space project designed to learn something.
CM 2.0
NASA’s new way to choose mission ideas.
flagship missions
Very large space missions.
💡 The gist
- NASA will judge science ideas before detailed plans.
- First proposals should need less work.
- Some smaller missions may need one review round.
NASA is changing how it chooses science missions. A mission is a space project for learning. The new system is called Competition Model 2.0, or CM 2.0. NASA explained it in a letter from Nicola Fox. NASA's letter and Space.com's report describe the plan.
The old process asked teams for too much too early. Teams explained the science, engineering, costs, and operations. NASA used a two-step competition. It could take almost three years. Losing teams still spent much time and money.
CM 2.0 puts science first. Teams first explain what they want to learn. They also give a simple plan. They show an early design idea. They can add many technical details later. This could help smaller teams compete. It could also give scientists more time for research.
Discovery, New Frontiers, and Astro-Probes keep two stages. Their first proposals will need about half the old material. Their timeline could fall from 35 months to 19.5 months. NASA calls this a possible reduction of up to 45 percent.
MIDEX and Earth Explorer missions also keep two stages. Universities and businesses can take part more easily. NASA will check past work on similar projects. Teams can ask Goddard or JPL for help.
Smaller missions will use one stage. These include Small Explorer and Earth Venture missions. They also include rideshares and hosted instruments. Final selection could fall from 32 months to 19 months. That would be a possible reduction of up to 40 percent. Large flagship missions will keep their current process.
NASA also wants useful commercial space tools. It will use them when they save money or improve technology. Cost and schedule rules will remain strict. A mission could still be cancelled if it breaks important limits.
The new system is only a plan so far. NASA will introduce it in stages. It will adjust the rules after hearing feedback. We do not know if missions will launch sooner. We also do not know if the reviews will stay fair.
Watch the next proposal calls. They will show the real rules. Later missions will show whether the plan works. The key evidence will be science, cost, and time.
NASA is changing how it picks space plans
📰 Full story: NASA wants to choose science missions faster—and more often
NASA (America's space agency) is changing how it picks space plans.
NASA
America’s space agency.
mission
A space plan for learning.
CM 2.0
NASA’s new way to pick plans.
NASA (America's space agency) is changing how it picks space plans. A mission is a space plan for learning. The new way is called CM 2.0. It looks at the big science question first. It checks small building details later. Old contests could take almost three years. Some small missions may go from 32 months to 19 months. Big missions will keep their current way. NASA still checks costs and schedules carefully. The plan may help more teams share ideas. We do not know if launches will become faster. Sources: NASA Science and Space.com.